Best Rated Mattress, Best Mattress Reviews Online
2008's Top Rated Mattress, Topper & Pillow
Based on Reviews, Ratings, Popularity, and Return Rate
Select Foam helps tens of thousands of customers each year, and we are often asked what our "Best" or "Top Rated" products are. And while every product we offer is held to the highest standards, a few products have out-shadowed the rest. So here it is, a section dedicated to our most highly rated mattress, toppers and memory foam pillows. We took into consideration the following criteria: Numerical Ratings and Reviews, Popularity, Return Rate, and General Feedback.
NOTE: These ratings are taken across a very large group of customers, each with unique needs and preferences. Please consider your unique needs and wants prior to purchasing a new product, and consult our sleep specialists with any questions.
Top Rated Mattress: Regalis HD 11"
![]() |
|
$1499 |
|
$1799 |
The Regalis HD 11" is consistently one of our top selling memory foam mattresses. The Suede and Cool-Tek Cover have an impeccable look. The HD memory foam provides more pressure relief than the average memory foam mattress. It is one of the coolest sleeping memory foam mattresses in the world. Constructed nearly identically to the TempurPedic Rhapsody, the Regalis HD gives you the same comfort and styling for literally 40% less.
The feedback, however, is what clearly marks the Regalis HD as our top mattress. It is our top rated mattress in terms of reviews and ratings, and we often have customers refer friends and family to us after trying this bed. This mattress also has an extremely low return rate: 1.2%.
Honorable Mention: Luxuria 10"
The Luxuria 10" received similar ratings and a return rate under 2%, in addition to being very popular. Many customers purchase this bed after trying the comparable TempurPedic Deluxe Bed, due to the similar feel and design.
The Luxuria 10", however, has not created the feedback frenzy of the Regalis HD, and therefore did not take first place. It should be mentioned, however, that the President and co-founder of the company sleeps on this mattress.
Click here to view the Luxuria
Top Rated Topper: 3" Select HD Memory Foam Topper


Click here to view our toppers starting at $229
We offer memory foam toppers in several thicknesses, and while we receive similar ratings on or mattress topper pads regardless of thickness, the 3" Select HD Topper is by far the best seller. At about a third of the cost of the Tempurpedic Overlay, it is a far better value with the same 5.3lb density memory foam. If you are under 250 pounds and want to transform an ordinary mattress into a luxury mattress, this is for you.
READ: Under What Situations can a Topper be added to MY existing mattress.
Top Rated Pillow: Comfort Pillow

Click here to view our comfort pillows starting at $89
The Select Foam Comfort Pillow once again wins the award for top rated pillow. It's conventional shape and pressure relieving memory foam chips cradles the head and neck in any position, while the low price tag of only $99 makes it much more affordable than comparable pillows. This is by far our most popular pillow.







